12 Essential Elements for A Successful Etsy Shop – (Part 2)

Introduction: This is the 2nd part of this blog, 12 Essential Elements for a successful Etsy Shop will help you set up and grow your Etsy Shop to generate additional income to run alongside your Photography Business.

Look at what successful Etsy sellers with similar products are charging. This will give you an idea of the price range within your niche. Be sure to compare products that are truly similar in terms of quality, materials and craftsmanship. 

Factoring in Etsy Fees: 

Remember to factor in all costs, including Etsy fees, shipping, and materials, and Etsy ads if you decide to run when setting your prices. Etsy fees include listing fees, transaction fees, and payment processing fees, all of which can add up. Use an Etsy fee calculator to help ensure you’re not underpricing your products. You can check one out here. At the time of writing this, Etsy is rolling out a calculation on the Etsy listing page which will give you estimated costs after any making and selling costs, so keep an eye out for that handy feature. There is a more detailed spreadsheet which is also available, you can check it out here.

Offering Discounts Strategically:

Offering discounts can be a great way to attract customers and make more Etsy sales, but they should be used strategically. Consider offering discounts during holidays, for first-time buyers, or for customers who purchase multiple items. Make sure your discounts don’t eat too much into your profit margins. 

7. Exceptional Customer Service: 

Have you ever shopped at a major high street store and had the worst customer service? I have, and it annoys me as it makes me feel that I’m not valued as a customer. I’ve also shopped at smaller independent shops, both online and in physical stores, the majority of the time the customer service has been outstanding! From their attentiveness, packaging and follow-up with ‘how are you getting on with your purchase’ type of messaging. Let’s look a little closer at this subject as customer satisfaction is so important.

Responding to Customer Inquiries

Aim to respond to customer inquiries as quickly as possible. Even if you don’t have an immediate answer, acknowledging the message and letting the customer know you’re working on it can go a long way in building trust.

Follow-Up After Sales: 

Consider sending a follow-up message after a sale to thank the customer and confirm that their order has shipped if you’re selling ship-to-door products. This not only shows that you care about their experience but also provides an opportunity to address any potential issues before they lead to negative reviews. Customer loyalty is so important to any business but even more so on Etsy as the amount of sellers since Covid has dramatically increased from 3 million to over 9.6 million at the time of writing this blog in 2024. 

Handling Returns and Exchanges:

Be clear about your returns and exchanges policy, and make sure it’s easy for customers to find. If a customer needs to return or exchange an item, handle the process professionally and efficiently to maintain their satisfaction.

8. Clear Returns/Exchanges Policy, Cancellations and More: 

Having clear policies regarding returns, exchanges, and cancellations is crucial for protecting both your business and your customers. Transparent policies help set expectations and reduce the likelihood of disputes.

Crafting a Clear Returns Policy: 

Your returns policy should clearly outline the conditions under which you accept returns, the timeframe customers have to return items, and who is responsible for return shipping costs. Be sure to include any exceptions, such as custom or digital products. You’ll find that the majority of digital products have a disclaimer attached so no refunds will be given. 

Cancellations and Exchanges:

Outline your policy for order cancellations and exchanges as well. Let customers know if there’s a time limit for cancelling an order and if there are any products that can’t be exchanged. Being upfront about these policies can help avoid misunderstandings and keep customers happy.

If you’re selling digital photographs/products, you can see on the recent orders page if the customer has downloaded their purchase; you can refund if they come to you saying they purchased in error, this is entirely your choice. I should say that in the years I’ve been selling digital products, I’ve never had a customer ask for a refund, so this scenario is rare but worth mentioning. 

Communicating Policies Effectively:

Make sure your policies are easy to find and clearly communicated in your shop. Include links to your policies in your product descriptions, shop announcements, and confirmation emails. This transparency builds trust and can lead to a more positive experience. 

9. Info and Appearance:

The overall appearance of your Etsy shop, including your shop information, plays a significant role in creating a professional and inviting atmosphere. This includes your shop announcement, the way your shop is organised, ad the aesthetic appeal of your shop as a whole. 

Shop Announcement:

This is one of the first things customers see when they visit your Etsy store. Use this space to communicate important information such as current promotions, shipping times, or new products. Keep it concise and update it regularly to reflect any changes or special events. 

Organising Your Shop:

A well-organised shop is easier for customers to navigate, which can lead to increased sales. Use sections to categorise your products logically, such as by type, season or theme. This makes it easier for potential customers to find what they’re looking for without having to sift through unrelated items.

Aesthetic Consistency:

The visual consistency of your shop is key to creating a cohesive and professional look. Your shop banner, product photos, and even the colour scheme of your shop should all align with your brand identity. This consistency helps in building trust and makes your shop more memorable. 

Incorporating a QR Code:

Consider adding a QR code in your shop banner or shop announcement that links to your social media profile, a landing page as previously mentioned of a specific product listing on Etsy. This can make it easier for customers to connect with your on other platforms or revisit your shop in the future.

10. A Glimpse Behind the Scenes: 

In the increasingly competitive Etsy marketplace, giving customers a glimpse behind the scenes can humanise your brand and build a deeper connection. Treat your online shop as you would a high street shop, where customers know the people behind the products. 

The Person Behind the Shop:

One of the unique aspects of Etsy is the opportunity for customers to connect with the makers/designers/artists. Including a bio or even better a short video about yourself – the Etsy shop owner- helps customers feel more connected to you and your products. Share your story, why you started your shop and what inspires your creations. 

Behind-the-Scenes Content: 

Behind-the-scenes content can include photos or videos of your workspace, the process of creating your products or even sneak peeks of upcoming items. Do you frame your own work? Do you use your skills to create photographic art from old pictures? This not only adds authenticity to your brand but also provides engaging content for your social media channels. 

Building Customer Trust:

When customers see the person behind the shop and the effort that goes into creating each item, it builds trust. This can lead to a loyal customer base that values not just the products you sell, but the passion and craftsmanship behind them. 

11. Stats and Conversion Rate: 

Understanding your Etsy stats and conversion rates is crucial for assessing your shop’s performance and making data-driven decisions. Good stats to aim for can vary depending on whether you’re selling digital products or physical items, but there are key metrics every Etsy shop owner should monitor.

Key Metrics to Track:

Some of the most important stats to track include views, visits, and conversion rate. Views refer to the number of items your products have been seen, while visits indicate how many individual customers have viewed your shop. Your conversion rate is the percentage of visits that result in a sale, which is a critical measure of your shop’s effectiveness.

Improving Your Conversion Rate:

If your conversion rate is low, consider revisiting your product descriptions, photos, pricing, and even your shipping policies. Small changes, such as updating product photos or tweaking your titles to better align with long-tail keywords, can have a significant impact on your conversion rate. 

Please remember as previously mentioned, don’t tweak any listing that is performing well, always make a copy and edit the copied version.

Setting Realistic Goals:

Depending on the type of products you sell, the average conversion rate can vary. Physical products tend to have different conversion rates compared to digital products, so it’s important to set realistic goals based on your specific market and product category. Regularly review your stats to track your progress and adjust your strategy as needed. 

12. Utilising Outside Social Media for Marketing Your Shop:

Social media is a powerful tool for driving traffic to your Etsy shop. By connecting your Etsy account with platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest, you can reach a wider audience and increase your chances of making sales. 

Making Connections to Social Media:

Etsy allows you to connect your shop directly to your social media profiles, making it easy to share new products, sales, and shop updates with your followers. By linking your shop to Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest you can drive more traffic to your Etsy listings and build a larger customer base. If you would like to know how you can successfully use Pinterest to market your photography business, you can check out my other blogs here.

Content Strategy for Social Media:

Develop a content strategy that includes a mix of promotional posts, behind-the-scenes content, and customer testimonials. Use social media to showcase your products in different settings, highlight special offers, and engage with your followers through comments and direct messages.

Paid Advertising on Social Media: 

Consider using paid advertising on platforms like Facebook and Instagram to reach a more targeted audience. These ads can be particularly effective when promoting new products or seasonal sales. Start with a small budget, and monitor the performance of your ads to see which ones generate the best results. 

Pinterest for Etsy Seller:

Pinterest is a particularly effective platform for Etsy sellers, as it acts as a visual search engine. If you’ve read any of my other blogs, you’ll know how much I love Pinterest! Create pinboards that showcase your products, and make sure each pin is optimised with relevant keywords and linked directly to your Etsy listings. Over time, your pins can drive significant traffic to your shop, especially if they are repined by others. 

In Conclusion: Running a successful Etsy shop involves much more than just listing products and waiting for sales to roll in. From branding and high-quality product photography to effective keyword research and excellent customer service, each element plays a critical role in your shop’s success. By paying attention to these 12 essential elements, you can stand out in the competitive Etsy marketplace, attract a loyal customer base, and ultimately turn your passion into a profitable business. With the right strategy, your Etsy shop can thrive, even in a marketplace with millions of sellers. 

I hope that both part 1 & part 2 of my 12 Essential Elements for a Successful Etsy Shop has given you valuable insight into setting up and running your Etsy shop.

Thanks so much for reading and supporting me. Photography Biz Success was set up to help and support photographers who struggle with the business side of their profession to achieve growth and success.

I would love to invite you to subscribe to my weekly emails which is full of valuable information and advice, more in-depth knowledge & in sights plus VIP product bundles to help make the day-to-day running of your business easier and more cost effective.

You can sign up to my weekly emails here.

I would like to wish you all the success in your photography biz. Please feel free to reach out and connect on any of my social channels, email or leave me a comment below.

Nicky x

BONUS PDF – 15-PAGE EBOOK ON SETTING UP YOUR SUCCESSFUL ETSY SHOP.

• Pinterest
• Instagram
• Facebook
• Etsy